It's all a lie...Joseph Carter used to be an amazing football player, but due to a silly mistake, he will be confined to a wheelchair for the rest of his life, taking away any chance of ever playing football again, along with all of his popularity. Since he's not a super-popular jock anymore, Joseph fears that he's just a bad kid with bad grades and a bad attitude.Mallory Day is always second best. At school, all anyone ever cares about is Trista, the most popular girl in school. Mallory wants to be first for once. In hopes of making everyone see how imperfect Trista really is, Mallory goes hunting to find something about Trista that might make people see a side of her that they've never seen before. But what if the truth was meant to stay hidden?Trista Vern broke up with her boyfriend, Joseph, shortly after it became clear he would never walk again. Without his popularity, she just doesn't see anything in him. But when Trista has no choice but to reveal a shocking secret to some of her classmates, she realizes that sometimes, telling the truth can lift a heavy burden. But when Trista and her friends are forced to keep the truth hidden for a dangerous reason, they have to decide: Keep quiet, and stay safe, or tell the truth, and risk everything?So when all three teenagers have reasons to remember Lynna Hail, a teenager who disappeared two years ago, they find out what the others know, and that their mistakes weren't the only ones that took place that night...