In part 1, navy veteran and high school history teacher Ron lost his beloved wife Annie to sudden onset cancer, only to find out later she was murdered. He met and fell in love with two women: June, his former student, and Halsey, a stunning Latina with Annie's wit and humor. Both women needed the love of an honorable man to save them, which he did. Now age 65 and having loved both of them for over 20 years, the angel Grace sends him back in time 24 years to the time before Annie got sick and before they fell in love with him. He must choose between saving her or saving June and Halsey again. Grace warns him tempting fate may not yield the outcome he desires.