In Penny's Wish, a young girl named Penny faces the exciting, yet overwhelming task of choosing her birthday wish with the help of her brother Teddy. With her big imagination, Penny dreams up a variety of fantastical possibilities-from living beneath the sea as a mermaid to carrying kids high in the sky as a ferris wheel. As each whimsical wish plays out in her mind, the magic leaps off the page, making it difficult for Penny to decide which one is truly her heart's desire. Each great idea comes with a downside, as lovingly pointed out by Teddy. Ultimately, she learns that wishing to become someone else would take out the joys of being a kid, and being herself is the most fun of all!