Louise Lambright had never been so confused. She fears her infatuation with Mark Jones, the Englischer next door, is not the Lord's will, but she seems to have little control over it. Mark is fun, friendly, and fascinating. Louise secretly wonders if he might be willing to convert to the Amish faith for her. At the same time, there stands Gabriel, a fine Amish man she's known since they were kinner. What she feels for Gabriel is different, not burning or heart-racing, yet powerful and enduring. Will Mark be willing to change his faith for her? How long can she continue to waver between these two men? Will Louise follow the path she's been taught since infancy, and what will happen when she confronts her true feelings?